Was Council’s Whitewater Decision made in the Public Interest?

Since local councils and elected councillors are required to act in the public interest, it follows that the public interest test should be fundamental to the decisions of our Council.  Equally, the test of the public interest test might be expected to show an investment of time, resources, intellect and discussion of the public interest.  

After the events of the General Meeting of May 2024, it remains unclear where and when or if the public interest was deliberated before the Council made its decision to support a whitewater facility at Birkdale.  

When was the public interest in a white water facility decided?

When the Council debated “Continued Support for the Redland Whitewater Centre” at the General Meeting on 15 May 2024 there was no mention of the Principles of the  Local Government Act, particularly the public interest in having a white water facility.

This omission is evidenced in the almost 100 pages of the agenda item, and the hour and 20 minutes of formal debate among Councillors.  

So while the Councillors debated what seemed operational issues they failed to demonstrate how they addressed the question (see principle LGA S4 (2) (a)) and how they had deployed … transparent and effective processes, and decision-making in the public interest.  

Councillors failed to acknowledge how public interest weighed upon their decision-making and this despite some of them having an avowed commitment to community values. 

Public interest is described in Wikipedia as ”the welfare or well-being of the general public” and society.  But with the Council having dispensed with any overt commitment to the public interest, the Redlands community witnessed a lengthy, messy and unedifying debate canvassing issues about profitability, specialised reports, expert opinions and the views of an unelected senior officer who displayed professional views on matters of financial viability, profit, future design solutions, environmental impacts, maintenance costs, Olympic spin-offs and the tiresome Redlands cliche about putting the city on some mythical map. This cliche was favoured by the former Mayor but that was before the failure of her Toondah development and her career-ending traffic accident.  

Despite the thousands of words in the agenda and the recorded debate, there is no discussion about the mandatory obligations to the public interest. Perhaps a proper resolution of this question would have avoided a lot of the debate about the Council’s mysterious fascination with what is a tiny piece of Olympic action. 

With so much of the information put forward to justify the decision taken by the Council and how it is reliant on consultant reports and other organisations, the question of the public interest is overlooked, but surely it is a matter for elected Councillors to decide.  

Should public interest include whether the community wants the facility?  Does it need the facility? Is it an important facility for the City? Where does it rate among the multitude of needs of the city (such as a new aquatic centre, its heating, lifesavers at the SMBI pool, quality of football fields, provision for pickleball or an indoor stadium)? Those questions and more seem likely to be a priority over and above the Olympic hype and legacy that was put forward in the debate of 14.1 at the General Meeting.  

Despite the lengthy debate (1 hour and 20 minutes) and an exhaustive agenda paper (over 100 pages) there is no statement that the whitewater facility facility was or is in the public interest.  So the question remains, did the elected Councillors of Redland City consider whether or not the Birkdale whitewater facility is in the public interest? There is no evidence that this question was considered!!!

Officers recommendations 

The Agenda Paper Item 14 of the meeting of 15 May was headed – Continued support for the Redland Whitewater Centre. In the report by Council Officers, it was stated that their report was to enable the Council to satisfy the Queensland Government’s requirement that the Council must confirm support for the Whitewater Centre. So it is documented that the report canvassed: 

  • delivery partner arrangements 
  • Redland Whitewater Centre funding and delivery
  • Status of Project Validation Report process
  • Assurance process
  • Urgency

The Strategic Implications were reported as being:

  • Legislative Requirements
  • Risk Management 
  • Financial
  • People
  • Environmental
  • Social 
  • Human rights
  • Alignment with Council Policy and Plans

The report failed to mention the public interest and failed to discuss documented community objections.  No Councillor posed the question but surely such oversight should have been noted and even remedied by the CEO? 

 Why wasn’t public interest on the agenda?

While item 14.1 was discussed for over 1 hour and 20 minutes in all that noise and all those words there is no reference to the public interest. 

A clear statement and a sound argument about the public interest of the Whitewater facility. Was the public interest neglected, overlooked or ignored?  Was the test of the public interest delegated to consultants? Was it referred to other organisations?  Was it delegated to Officers?

Probably not, because the questions of the public interest are uniquely matters for the elected Councillors!  It seems they didn’t ask how the Council would respond to the test for the public interest and prima facie the decision-making process has failed!

Do you think Councillors decided whether the Birkdale whitewater facility was in the public interest? Is there evidence that the approach accorded with the local government principles?  Your response needs to be relayed to Divisional councillors as soon as possible and there needs to be a recision motion “engineered” so that the right process is put in place and a proper assessment of the public interest used to inform the decision-making! 

Public interest in the Birkdale whitewater facility:

The level of concern and the measure of public interest can be drawn from the following measures of public opinion, it all adds up to an overwhelming rejection of the white water facility, but these views were dismissed or given little weight by the elected decision-makers:

1. Council Consultation: Out of 1,680 responses, 78.8% favored lower-impact activities like nature trails and conservation, while only 8.9% supported the whitewater facility. This overwhelming preference for alternatives was reportedly dismissed by some councillors, including Cr. MacKenzie, who attributed negative feedback to misinformation.

2. Local Government Infrastructure Designation (LGID) Polling: In 2023, 142 out of 172 submissions opposed the whitewater project. Despite this, the Council decided to proceed with the project in a 7-4 vote.

3. Parliamentary Petition: A petition against the whitewater facility gathered 2,574 signatures. The Council did not even acknowledge this substantial opposition which was much bigger than other Parliamentary Petitions including one in 2018 sponsored by the then Mayor that called for action on the Eastern Busway.  This attracted only 921 signatures.

4. Election results: There was of course an even bigger test of public opinion during the recent Local Government election. Mayor Mitchell made her position very clear and she iterated over and over. Her position and this was widely reported in the media and no doubt influenced her landslide victory. Her conclusion was cited at the general meeting on 15 May when she said…..” 

so I’m stuck with the vast majority of feedback not being in favour of the white water facility. I come back to people and place, so in my function as an elected representative, I have to give weight to what the community’s feedback is. And the community feedback through my election phase was very clear. And I can’t I can’t get around that”. Mayor Mitchell voted according to her pre-election perspective and her pre-election commitments.

The election of Mayor, Jos Mitchell, was a landslide result and was strongly influenced by her public position on the whitewater facility.  The other mayoral candidates held diametrically opposite positions but they were “trumped” by primary and preferential votes.  After preferences, Jos Mitchell received an impressive 67.7% of votes.  It is clear the public vote correlated with the new mayor’s pre-election stance.

5. Assessment of Councillor’s Decision: The decision to proceed with the whitewater facility was narrowly approved by a 6-5 vote. The six councillors who supported the facility had fewer votes in their respective divisions compared to the Mayor, who had a broader mandate reflecting public opposition to the facility. In divisions 2,5,6,7,8 and 9 the total vote for those Councillors supporting the motion was 32 324 while in those divisions, the total vote for Mayor Mitchell was 39555 (after preferences). This discloses that the councillors’ 6-5 decision did not align with the majority opinion of the constituents in divisions 2,5,6,7,8 and 9.

Did the debate and decision-making process adequately address how the facility would serve the public interest or the substantial community feedback?

6. Community Surveys and Feedback: A subsequent survey conducted in July 2024 revealed that 78.9% of respondents opposed the whitewater facility, with only 9.5% in favour. This result further underscores the disconnect between the councillors’ decision and community sentiment and significantly …. the likely public interest. 

The high level of awareness about the facility among residents (82.8%) and the overwhelming opposition suggest that the decision made by the Council was out of step with public opinion.

Conclusion

The Birkdale Whitewater facility decision by the council raises significant concerns about whether the public interest was ever adequately considered. The process lacked explicit discussion of public interest, and failed to address substantial community opposition, and did not align with the principles of transparent and effective governance as required by the LGA. The glib commentary by the majority of Councillors blamed those people taking an active role in local democracy as “usual suspects”, the “same cohort” and the like. There were even adverse comments about the use of proforma submissions, which shows some Councillors are well out touch with how people like to participate in local affairs.

Given the available and documented evidence, it seems that the Councillors who voted in favour of “Continued Support for the Redland Whitewater Centre” should urgently advise their constituents how their (personal) decision was made and why they ignored available and overwhelming evidence of the public attitude and the public interest?

Redlands2030 – 4 September 2024

3 thoughts on “Was Council’s Whitewater Decision made in the Public Interest?”

  1. Well done R2030 but surely someone knows how we got to this?

    The lack of awareness about essential and legal obligations by Councillors is made worse by plenty of examples of pointless “points of order”. Surely our Council can refute, explain or apologise. Where is our Councillor protecting community values when we need her?

    All we need is a proper argument detailing how whitewater is in the public interest (if it is?) and that might engender community discussion and debate that people could follow and even participate in…but then maybe Councillors don’t want that level of transparency!

    Irrespective, as it stands, the Council’s white water decision looks illegitimate!!

  2. The evidence is quite clear. Those Councillors who voted for this proposal, abrogated their responsibility to the ratepayers they represent. They should be held accountable for this travesty and advised as such of their failing to meet their constitutional and legal responsibility.

    Where is the means of redress? In our hands, by writing to your local Councillor and drawing attention to the facts in this article.

    I shall be writing to the Councillor for Ward 2 and pointing out he doesn’t represent himself, a developer or anyone else but those ratepayers in his Ward. That was what he was elected to do and by I understand, a VERY narrow margin.

    P.O. Cleveland

  3. Having knowledge of the Penrith White Water facility problems. I would have been one of the first rate payers to raise my concerns with our Council. I was advised that, the two facilities were nowhere near the same and that the Birkdale facility, according to the business plan would be inundated with users both before and after the Olympics. I requested a copy of the documentation and was told that it was “Commercial in Confidence” and not available to the general public. My grandmother used to say, “none is as deaf as those who do not want to hear” and this is true of our Council and its bureaucracy who clearly have forgotten who they are employed by.
    Unfortunately, we ger what we vote for when we do not take the time to properly evaluate people standing for Council. My local member says I am not in their ward when clearly I am.
    Did the Council act in the Public Interest? The answer is clearly No they did not, and we must continue to object to both the Council and State and Federal Ministers as well.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top