Straddie parking, Council projects and the proposed Olympic whitewater stadium, in letters to Redlands2030

The future of the proposed whitewater stadium and other contentious Redlands projects are discussed in letters to Redlands2030.

And there’s a short letter about car parking spaces at the One Mile water taxi terminal.

If you have something to say, email your letter to theeditor@redlands2030.net


Parking at One Mile

On Stradbroke Island at One Mile water taxi, where parking is at a premium, there is but one disability parking space.

This is neglect of the elderly as the population of Straddie ages.

Please bring this matter to the attention of the newly appointed Mayor.

G.W.
Straddie


Is the Birkdale Whitewater proposal in the public interest?

whitewater
“Isn’t it about time you took an interest in this issue that will have significant impacts with your future Council rates? “

Under the Stated Principles of the Australian Press Council, ‘Public Interest’ is defined as ‘involving a matter capable of affecting the people at large so they might be legitimately interested in, or concerned about, what is going on, or what may happen to them or to others’.

The recent Local Government Elections in the Redlands firmly established the clear determination of local ratepayers about the Birkdale Whitewater proposal. 7 out of 10 ratepayers voted along with the current Mayor, thereby specifically not supporting the Birkdale Whitewater proposal.

When the Redlands Council votes on any matter concerning the public, Councillors are required under the Local Government Act, to reflect ratepayer wishes, under the principles of ‘Public Interest’. Yet at a meeting after the election, a 6/5 majority of councillors insisted on continuing to vote in favour of the Whitewater proposal. 

How this apparent disconnection occurred between those Councillors who voted for this proposal and ratepayers remains a real mystery. If one applies the definition of the Press Council’s definition of ‘Public Interest’, it appears those Redlands Councillors who voted in favour of this proposal sure wouldn’t pass the ‘Pub Test’.

In Queensland, the State government has the power to require local government to follow government decisions. This power extends to decisions like the Birkdale Whitewater proposal.

Given the current Council’s slim majority vote approval, if the State government decides there must be a Whitewater facility in the Redlands, local ratepayers will have to fund the maintenance and ongoing costs of this facility. A facility clearly provided for the very few our ratepaying community.

The matter then becomes even more curious. There is already a suitable Whitewater facility in Penrith NSW, a leftover from the Sydney Olympics. This facility clearly meets all the Olympic Committee’s requirements. It was also reported that the Penrith council could not afford the upkeep of the existing Whitewater facility, and responsibility had to be funded by the State government.

In addition, there are some extremely serious environmental concerns that have been raised about the siting of the Birkdale proposal. 

Isn’t it about time you took an interest in this issue that will have significant impacts with your future Council rates? 

When’s the last time you spoke to your local Councillor? 

Here’s a list of those Councillors who voted (without explanation) against the obvious public opinion (Crs Talty, Mckenzie, Huges, Colley, Mitchell and Rendalls) and those who voted in line with public opinion (Crs Boglary, Golle, Bishop, and Hewlett along with Mayor Jos Mitchell).

Paul Oates
Cleveland


Redland City Council projects

whitewater
“…what will Council do about all the projects that are on the books…”

Its timely after such a momentous election to ask what are the implications for Redlands?

The big question is what will Council do about all the projects that are on the books e.g., Toondah Harbour upgrade, the State Government housing plans and of course the Birkdale Olympic whitewater project. The message should be plain and clear, it cannot be business as usual.

Now is the time to say to our Council, clean out the books and scratch off all the projects signed off with Labour. The issue of funding must be investigated so that we the ratepayers aren’t left picking up the bills.

Lets make sure that the books are cleaned out and that any money going out the door is fully accounted for. As always we must be vigilant and proactive to keep our Council honest and our money safe.

We need a new hospital and roads NOT a white elephant Olympic venue!

J Ontheball
Redlands


Birkdale, whitewater and public opinion

Penrith Whitewater Stadium can be used for the 2032 Olympics
Penrith Whitewater Stadium

We know with recent community surveys – and if this letters page is any guide – the weight of public opinion in Redlands is overwhelmingly against the proposed Whitewater Centre at Birkdale. 

For a new Government with its eye on eliminating wasteful Olympic spending, avoiding Budget outlays when world-class venues such as Penrith exist for niche whitewater Olympic events is a policy no-brainer. 

And one in total accord with International Olympic Committee policy on venue re-use – being the key plank in its strategy for financially sustainable Games as it struggles to entice cities to host them.   

Though impeding sensible decision making it seems, is the classic ill-founded Queensland parochialism that dictates as a Brisbane games there can be no countenancing of alternative non-Queensland event locations – regardless of the benefit.

But such misplaced intransigence is ultimately bad news for both Redland ratepayers and Queensland taxpayers – who will bear the financial burden of owning and maintaining this whitewater white elephant. 

To that end, a compromise appears to exist whereby the City of Penrith is formally recognised as a Brisbane 2032 Games Partner, and assigned “Brisbane Sister City” status for the Games duration.

The branding of a Brisbane Games is then not diluted. Further, the Olympic Canoe-Slalom events ticketing could be prioritised for Queensland residents, with travel subsidised from a fraction of the savings of this avoided whitewater construction.  

A Win-Win in every case.  

M.M.
Redland Bay

More Letters To Redlands2030

Footpath fail, new Toondah plans and Olympic venues review in letters to Redlands2030

Letter writers disheartened because governments … don’t listen

Guerilla wombats, whitewater public opinion, Toondah views and the widening generation gap

Redlands2030 – 30 November 2024

1 thought on “Straddie parking, Council projects and the proposed Olympic whitewater stadium, in letters to Redlands2030”

  1. Infrastructure, emergency services and parks and recreation are part of the Birkdale project. If redlanders want higher rates they should continue to vote against the projects that will benefit the area.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top