Selective hearing, aged care changes, and speaking up: Letters

The Queensland Premier’s selective hearing, recent concerns about increases to the cost of aged care services, and a call for people to speak up about matters of public interest, are discussed in three letters to the Editor.

If you have something to say, email us at: theeditor@redlands2030.net


The Premier’s selective hearing of community opinion

Selective hearing - Gold Coast light rail is cancelled but not the more unpopular Birkdale whitewater proposal.
Gold Coast Light Rail – Photo: Philip Mallis, accessed from Wikimedia Commons.

I watched with great interest the news from the Premier that he had listened to the 67% of southern Gold Coast residents who were opposed to a light rail through their suburbs. In response he stopped the construction of the Gold Coast light rail Stage 4.

That’s a big turnabout. However, his actions highlight the completely different approach he took in ignoring up to 78% of Redland City residents who DO NOT want a whitewater facility at Birkdale!

A community initiated survey found 78% of Redland City residents DO NOT want a whitewater centre in Birkdale. This data was supported by the Redlands local newspaper, The Redland Bayside News, which did an online poll asking if readers wanted the proposed whitewater venue. The result – an equally resounding 73% said NO.

But the Whitewater debacle is proceeding based on a seeming whim of the Government and a few loud voices.

Further, my assessment (confirmed by the editor) of community opinion in letters to the Editor of the local newspaper revealed a staggering 90% were against the Olympic whitewater centre. I look forward to an explanation from the Government or one of our local MPs for the anomaly.

The question now is why the overwhelming views of local residents on the Gold Coast are treated with rightful deference but views of Redlanders are completely ignored or overridden …….when an even stronger preference stands against a pet project of “the few”.

The Premier should be able to join these dots!!!!

K.E.
Birkdale

selective hearing

Editor’s note: Here is the State Government’s media statement about not proceeding with Gold Coast light rail Stage 4.



Unfair aged care

More information about changes to aged care funding

While $54 billion is being used for NDIS, it is wrong that  people in aged care who have worked all their lives are now being told to pay for 80 percent of their care. I am not surprised that they are angry.

Watching the news tonight was an eye opener. The amount of money wasted by NDIS is appalling. Many people, both receivers and carers, are rorting the system while people who have worked all their lives miss out.

On top of that, the service providers also seem to do alright from the trough. It’s time to call it out.

People in aged care have worked all their lives; now they should benefit from the taxes they have paid. Many people on NDIS seem to be using NDIS as an alternative to the dole. The dole requires you to apply for jobs and go to interviews. Getting on NDIS is a way of avoiding responsibility. Time to halve the support.

This way people who have worked get acknowledged and even slightly rewarded for their contribution. 

J.F.
Logan Reserve 


Speak up!

Community action about the Toondah Harbour PDA – February 2014

Why are so many people apathetic when it comes to public issues?

Week after week, important decisions are made that shape our environment, our neighbourhoods, and our future. On the pages of Redlands2030 we see a small handful of people willing to speak up. For years I asked myself whether my effort would matter — but I’ve come to realise that even small actions, like signing a petition, attending a meeting, or writing a letter, can help shift the balance.

Too often we tell ourselves we’re too busy, or that one voice won’t make a difference. Many assume “someone else” will do it. But when everyone thinks that way, the result is that silence becomes the loudest response. And silence is too easily taken (or taken by Government and council) as consent.

The danger of apathy is that it hands power to those already well-organised and well-resourced. It erodes democracy, weakens community, and silences shared values.

Breaking the pattern doesn’t take much. A few minutes to write. A few words spoken in public. A few signatures gathered. Small acts, multiplied, show leaders that people are paying attention. I’m heartened by the way ordinary people responded to the way the Disney Corporation response to the actions of thousands of ordinary people and restored Jimmy Kimmel to his TV program. Hence I wrote this letter.

The real risk isn’t speaking up. The real risk is staying silent — and letting others decide our future for us.

N.M.
Cleveland


More letters to Redlands2030

Hospital car parking, whitewater cost shifting, and middens cover up – in letters

Council bickering, whitewater fiasco and Russian oil in letters

Sirromet and the Southern Thornlands PDA – in letters

Redlands2030 – 27 September 2025

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top