Furious Raby Bay residents threaten legal action

Raby Bay resident Zrinka Johnston recently slammed Redland City Council for its canal maintenance works, alleging serious violations of good governance and proper accountability as well as apparent transgressions of statutory and regulatory provisions.

“Council has been seriously inept and incompetent in administering the Raby Bay levy and constructing engineering works efficiently.” said Ms Johnston in a speech to Council at its public meeting on 9th May.

Council’s community consultation process about canal maintenance “appeared to be a subterranean attempt to reduce or exit Council’s involvement in Raby Bay canal management and funding” she said.

A slightly abridged version of Ms Johnston’s speech to Council is published below. Her speech can also be viewed on the meeting video recording, commencing at 16 minutes.

Unexploded ordnances

 
There are four impending explosions I see in Council’s current Raby Bay canal works program:

1. Unacknowledged statutory obligations

Council has not acknowledged its statutory obligation under the Coastal Protection and Management Act to maintain navigability in Raby Bay canals.

There are three applicable CPMA sections:

  • 116 (the area of the canal must be surrendered to the State as a public waterway)
  • 121 (a local government must maintain and keep clean each canal in its area)
  • 124 Obligation to keep particular structure in safe condition: ….(a) a person who is owner of freehold land…if the land is above the high water mark…and receives the benefit of the structure….(b) anyone else including…a local government acting as a trustee.

I read these to mean that local government and benefitting landowners both have obligations but the landowner’s responsibility is limited to above high watermark structures.

2. Violating levy regulations

Council is flagrantly violating levy regulations by switching never ending canal works timelines into annual works programs with annual end-dates every year but still without a proper plan, still without proper budgeting and still without a proper end-date for the whole program of works.

Council has simply converted long term program management into annual projections. This violates the spirit of the regulation if not the letter of the law which requires a real end-date for the levy.

3. Raby Bay exiting: a consultation gone wrong

Council must now explain its wacky expensive (over $350,000?) community consultation on Raby Bay canals (and other waterfronts) or find a plausible apologetic conclusion on this misconceived “chat with all ratepayers” which had no public terms of reference.

Privately it appeared to everyone involved a subterranean attempt to reduce or exit Council’s involvement in Raby Bay canal management and funding. This has produced fire and fury in canal residents and a threat of legal action.

4. Open the black box

The canal works program is a black box which will produce havoc when it’s split open.

Council has continually proclaimed its openness and consultativeness and often proudly pronounced how much information it collects and holds on canal walls.

Our levy is paying for five canal system data collections each of which is incomplete and the five are incompatible and uncombinable.

I have been trying unsuccessfully for three years to get a map of Raby Bay canals with data. The little bit I got was through FOI and it was woefully inadequate.

Three months ago I changed tack and asked for basic information on my own wall, its location, dimensions and stability. There is still no reply. I will continue to try.

Please explain and remedy

I have been watching this over the past five years with great dismay. These are serious violations of good governance and proper accountability as well as apparent transgressions of statutory and regulatory provisions. I call on Council to please explain and remedy them.

There is a lot to remedy.

The program is too slow, far too expensive, heavily overweight in engineering and never evaluated for effectiveness. Over 20% of these expensive never-to-fail structures have failed, some more than once.

And to compound the problem, Council has failed to protect canal walls properly in the new town plan so the future looks bleak- many more tidal structures of high expense and an ever-growing levy impost on us.

Can I help?

I am here to offer my help in dismantling these bombs. I have in mind a way to construct a proper program of works with a plan, budget and end-date. It is your responsibility as Councillors to ask the CEO to produce this. I am willing to outline my proposal if you wish.

By the way Aquatic Paradise is different from Raby Bay for several reasons. And Sovereign Waters is not governed by the CPM Act because it is a lake and not tidal waters. So Raby Bay canals need a unique policy and program.

Please let me know if you would like me to come to another meeting and explain it.

 

Zrinka Johnston
Speech to Redland City Council on 9th May 2018

 

Published by Redlands2030 – 16 May 2018

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top