Toondah Harbour Part 2 – a priority development area

Twenty years ago, Redland City Council had a hankering for Toondah Harbour to be improved in a big, exciting, and money-making way.

Ernst & Young’s real estate advisory group was engaged in March 2006 to advise on improving Toondah Harbour’s amenity, facilities and infrastructure while “contributing economic benefit to the area”. Over the next 18 months other consultants assisted.

Key stakeholders such as the ferry operators, CSIRO, and the State Government, were consulted, but there was no community engagement – this was all strictly confidential. The consultants’ findings were considered in closed session meetings by the Council in November 2007.

Somehow, the story leaked. “A 400-berth marina, a yacht club and mixed-use apartment buildings would be built at Cleveland’s Toondah Harbour under a secret Redland Shire Council plan” reported the Brisbane Times.

This could involve 1,000 apartments in buildings up to seven storeys, the Brisbane Times said, citing confidential reports.

The officers’ report to Council in November 2007 pointed out that environmental impacts of the Council’s desired development could be tricky.

“Any proposal to undertake major works in the marine park environment will most likely trigger a Commonwealth Government review of the proposal under the Environmental Protection Biodiversity Conservation (EPBC) Act, as the Commonwealth government administers Australia’s obligations under international agreements such as RAMSAR”, said the officers’ report.

Redland City Council decided on 20 November 2007 to pick the option with the most potential for development, and to seek State Government agreement to “a workable delivery platform” for master planning Toondah Harbour.

The consultants suggested Council could have more influence on Toondah Harbour development by acquiring two properties from CSIRO. In 2010 Council bought from CSIRO a waterfront property for $3.5 million. A second larger property near Toondah Harbour was bought for $3.4 million in April 2012.

In 2011 Redland City Council hired GHD to provide a project plan for development of Toondah Harbour. GHD’s report, considered at a meeting on 14 December 2011, spelt out two key risks for the Council.

Firstly, the cost of dredging and earthworks was uncertain. GHD suggested that the Council do geo-technical studies estimated to cost about $1 million (in 2011 dollars).

The second key risk GHD mentioned was marine environment impacts. “The first step will be to seek a declaration as to whether the Project will trigger a controlled action under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (EPBC Act) said GHD.

2012 elections

In 2012 the political landscape changed. The LNP led by Campbell Newman won the State elections on 24 March. A few weeks later Redlands elected a pro-development council led by Mayor Karen Williams.

On 29 November 2012 Queensland Parliament passed the LNP Government’s Economic Development Act  which allowed the State to declare priority development areas with easier development approval pathways.

During parliamentary debate, Labor’s Jackie Trad slammed the proposed laws. Her speech on 28 November 2012 included comments such as:

Jackie Trad
Jackie Trad MP opposing the Economic Development Bill on 28 November 2012
  • The opposition cannot support elements of what is rushed and poorly conceived legislation that has been drafted with woefully inadequate consultation and that is targeted at two sets of interests, those of powerful mining companies and wealthy developers, to the detriment of the rest of the community. and
  • This is all about empowering the white shoe brigade and not local government or community groups.

Speaking about Deputy Premier Jeff Seeney who put forward the Economic Development Bill, Jackie Trad said: 

…the Deputy Premier has one position in opposition but another position when in government. He has another position when he has the full power of the responsibility of the Deputy Premiership.

Three years later, Jackie Trad would have the full power of the Deputy Premiership. People would remember what she said, when in opposition.

Priority development areas for Redlands

Redland City Council wanted four priority development areas (PDAs). During officer level discussions with the State Government in March 2013, the Council was persuaded to revise its wish list to just Toondah Harbour and Weinam Creek. State Government officers made it clear that the Council would be responsible for the cost of PDA planning studies.

On 1 May 2013, the Council resolved unanimously to ask the State Government for Toondah Harbour and Weinam Creek to be declared PDAs.

At a business breakfast in Redlands on 16 May 2013, Deputy Premier Jeff Seeney announced that Toondah Harbour and Weinam Creek would each be declared as a Priority Development Area (PDA). Mr Seeney set an 18-month timeframe to complete plans and start developing the site.

“The timeframe won’t be very long as the issues here are well known and we should be able to complete designs within six months and then move forward to the physical development side within 12 or 18 months,” Mr Seeney said.

These PDAs were formally declared by the Government on 21 June 2013. Over the next six months, several consultants prepared technical reports and drafted a development scheme for the Toondah Harbour and Weinam Creek PDAs.

Meanwhile, Mayor Karen Williams visited Asia and promoted investment opportunities including Toondah Harbour.


Toondah Harbour PDA Development Scheme

Early in 2014 the State Government and Redland City Council initiated public consultation about draft development schemes for the Toondah Harbour and Weinam Creek PDAs. Consultation was from 10 January to 24 February 2014.

The only information made available for public scrutiny was a 36 page Draft Development Scheme which provided for buildings with heights ranging from 7 to 15 storeys and a marina with up to 800 berths. And some artist’s impressions.

There was no mention of Ramsar wetlands and the need for Federal Government environmental approvals in the draft Development Scheme.

Face to face community engagement was poorly organised and limited to a total of about six hours during the consultation period. During one consultation activity a significant error was uncovered, as reported by the Redland City Bulletin.

Professional review of the Toondah Harbour PDA plan by several architects, engineers and planners working pro bono found that the Toondah Harbour development scheme was ill-conceived and “an unacceptable long-term risk for ratepayers”.

Shane Thompson, President of the Australian Institute of Architects Queensland Chapter at the time, was particularly critical. “This dreadful and grandiose PDA scheme is something of the type we would normally only expect of some lunatic despotic government in the Third World” he said.


In its response to community feedback, the Council said it would recommend that the State Government:

  • Cut maximum building heights from 15 to 10 storeys;
  • Halve the maximum number of marina berths from 800 to 400; and
  • Commit that open space will not be reduced as a result of the PDAs, including G.J. Walter Park.

Toondah Harbour needed “approximately $80 million in community infrastructure” said Mayor Karen Williams. “In order to keep rates low and have investors fund and improve the existing key infrastructure at Toondah Harbour, including establishing a maritime approved navigation channel, we know we need 800 residential and commercial units to pay for it” she said.

The final Development Scheme showing reduced building heights and development footprint was approved by the State Government in May 2014. It’s important to note that these plans don’t limit development, because the Scheme permits any development in the PDA consistent with the PDA vision.

Various technical reports underpinning the draft Development Scheme were not made publicly available until after the consultation period ended. This included information explaining the impact that development would have on Ramsar wetlands, as shown below.

BAAM Plan dated 18 December 2013 showing matters of national environmental significance which was not disclosed by Redland City Council during the Toondah Harbour PDA consultation period

Walker Group becomes preferred Toondah Harbour developer

Toondah Harbour
Deputy Premier Jeff Seeney, Walker Group Chairman Lang Walker, and Redlands Mayor Karen Williams signing an MOU at the Grand View Hotel on 18 September 2014 – Photo Redlands2030

On 23 June 2014, developers were invited to express interest in development opportunities at the Toondah and Weinam Creek PDAs. Eight expressions of interest were received by the closing date of 28 July 2014, said the Council.

A few weeks later, on 3 September 2014, Redland City Council endorsed the selection of Walker Group as development partner for both the Toondah Harbour and Weinam Creek PDAs. Walker Group’s selection was announced at the Grand View Hotel in Cleveland on 18 September 2014.

At this time, Walker Group Chairman Lang Walker said that the company would “now commence detailed project planning” and that that they were “talking about” 1,000 dwellings.

Within two months, Walker Group had a preliminary land use plan strikingly similar to the 3,600 apartment Toondah Harbour Master Plan which it would unveil a year later. We know this, because plans dated November 2014 showing the larger development footprint were included in Walker Group’s first EPBC referral which was published in November 2015.

So by late 2014 Walker Group was already planning a huge development at Toondah Harbour. Then it was time for another election.

Plan dated 12 November 2014 prepared by Place Design Group for Walker Corporation. It appears in Walker Group’s first Toondah Harbour EPBC referral submitted.

Read More of the Toondah Harbour story

Toondah Harbour development – Part 1 “Everything in its favour”

Part 3 will examine what happened after the State elections in January 2015.

Redlands2030 – 12 May 2026

1 thought on “Toondah Harbour Part 2 – a priority development area”

  1. When we bought our home in Salisbury st Redland Bay, We had the QLD Agricultural centre in front of us and beside us.
    The road was narrow beyond our home up the hill and we had a shallow open culvert covered in grass that I mowed.
    It followed a natural watercourse that drained away to the bay.
    Never had water sitting in it as it drained to the bay.
    Council sold this land to developers and it now is completely covered in small block housing.
    Council allowed all the stormwater runoff from houses and roads to be connected to the original watercourses.
    The developers put in grit collecting tanks in to stop silting of the water courses & would pump them out every six months.
    When it was handed to council with a substantial bond left with council to cover costs.
    Council increased their revenues substantially without upgrading infrastructure.
    This is a common pattern with this council.
    I have been raising this issue with council for 16 years without any thing done.
    I now live beside a channel that has over a meter of filthy algae ridden water beside our home.
    This is because of no maintenance of the grit collecting tanks which has caused a damming of the water courses which are now full of bullrushes.
    We are constantly feeling unwell due to slime & algae.
    I now find myself having to pay a plumber to replace all of my stormwater pipes as the old pipes are blocked by all the sediment where they entered the creek.
    All I can say is if you live next to one of these developments get it in writing from council any adverse problems will be resolved immediately.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top