Results of poll assessing Mayor’s performance

An on-line poll conducted recently by Redlands2030 found less than 10% of respondents think Karen Williams has done a good job as Mayor of Redland City.

Poll finds less than 10% of respondents think Karen Williams has done a good job as Redland City Mayor.
Mayor Karen Williams

The poll was held on the Redlands2030 website over 18 days from 12 to 29 February 2020.

The question asked was:

Has Karen Williams done a good job as Mayor of Redland City?

The poll was included in a story which provided information about ‘pledges’ made by Karen Williams during her previous election campaign in 2016.

Information was also included about achievements claimed by Karen Williams in a story published recently by the Redland City Bulletin.

Results from responses to the Redlands2030 poll were not displayed until after polling concluded, to minimise the possibility of respondents being influenced by decisions of previous respondents.

Poll results

During the polling period there were 616 respondents to one question, as shown below.

Has Karen Williams done a good job as Mayor of Redland City?

All 616 responses

Response Yes No
Votes 59 557
% 9.6% 90.4%

We reviewed the Internet Protocol (IP) addresses of respondents to see if people may have posted more than one response.

Our analysis found a few instances of a multiple responses coming from a single IP address.

It is, of course possible multiple responses from a single IP address could be legitimate if for example a home computer is shared by people.

However, there is a risk of on-line poll results being distorted by individuals entering multiple responses.

Indeed, in 2019 Queensland’s Crime and Corruption Commission completed a preliminary investigation to inform its assessment of a complaint relating to the online voting process that sought public feedback on the renaming of Lady Cilento Children’s Hospital.

Poll results from unique IP addresses

When we removed all instances of additional results from any IP address this left us with responses from 559 unique IP addresses as shown below.

Has Karen Williams done a good job as Mayor of Redland City?

Responses from 559 unique IP addresses

Response Yes No
Votes 50 509
% 8.9% 91.1%

This resulted in a slight decrease in the percentage saying “Yes”, from 9.6% to 8.9%.

Either way you look at the results, it’s clear that the vast majority of respondents don’t think Karen Williams has done a good job as Mayor of Redland City.

So what?

RedlandsVotes

The question left to ponder is: are the respondents to this poll representative of the broader community?

It’s often said that the only poll which counts is the one on election day.

Local Government Elections will be held on 28 March 2020 with early voting available from 16 March at pre-poll centres in Cleveland, Victoria Point and Capalaba.

For information about the elections including latest available details of all known candidates check out the RedlandsVotes website.

Redlands2030 – 2 March 2020

 

 

 

 

 

 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top