Redland City Council is a dysfunctional group intent on internal bickering, infighting, and personal point scoring according to members of the community expressing their views in letters to Redlands2030.
Other letters discuss the unpopular Birkdale whitewater project, and question community awareness of Russian oil being imported to Australia despite Australia imposing sanctions to support Ukraine.
If you have something to say, email your letter to theeditor@redlands2030.net
Do we need Redland City Council?

I am starting to question the need for the Redland City Council. I naively thought that developing and implementing sensible building plans with community input while following the Council’s vision that reflects its agreed values, was a major role but, sadly, I see this is not the case.
Recently, developers have had current plans extended above original height restrictions, other planning powers have been taken over by the State Government and a local college seeks to circumvent the Council by applying for a Ministerial Infrastructure Designation for a major development that will significantly impact a koala habitat.
What has happened to our “Naturally wonderful lifestyle”, “Liveable Neighbourhoods” and “Natural Environment”? (Our Future Redlands – A Corporate Plan to 2026 and Beyond)
Meanwhile, the Council is coming across as a dysfunctional group more intent on personal point scoring than in serving the community and certainly not interested in transparency and definitely not adhering to its values of “One team, Serve with pride, Own it with integrity, Listen and be heard”. Perhaps it’s time to agitate for their removal.
J.D.
Cleveland
Council and “Our” Councillors have lost the plot

It’s time to ask whether the people of Redlands are getting the leadership they deserve from their elected Council.
In recent weeks and months, the performance of Redland City Councillors has been marked more by internal bickering than by any meaningful progress on issues that matter to the community. Instead of focusing on delivering results, too many are distracted by point-scoring, personality clashes, and procedural squabbles.
Public trust in local government depends on professionalism, transparency, and a shared commitment to community wellbeing. What we’re seeing instead is a Council divided, distracted, and dysfunctional. This is not just an embarrassment — it’s a barrier to good decision-making and effective governance.
The Mayor was elected by the people of Redlands with a clear mandate to lead. Whether individual councillors agree with her or not, that mandate deserves respect. Undermining the Mayor through constant obstruction and personal attacks is not only unprofessional — it’s a disservice to the voters.
There are major challenges facing our city — including planning decisions, environmental protection, and infrastructure pressures. But when Council time is consumed by infighting, how can residents have confidence that these matters are getting the attention they require?
Residents deserve better. Councillors are elected to represent us — not to fight each other. They need to lift their game, put personal differences aside, and get back to the job they were elected to do: working for the people of Redlands.
M.S.
Cleveland
Birkdale Whitewater fiasco

Reference is made to comments by Rebecca Young, MP, Member for Redlands including her advertisement wrapped around the Olympic edition of the Redland Bayside News.
Does Ms Young know this piece of land, protected from developers since WWII to preserve the Radio Receiving Station the US Army built, it is from where Australia heard news the war was over?
No mention of that, nor of Willard’s Farm, built by early European settlers mid-1800s. Under Williams’ Administration the structure would have been demolished for 12 houses had Capalaba Member Don Brown and the Environment Minister not acted to save it. Both structures are State Government Heritage listed and could attract tourism and visitors from overseas.
Ms Young speaks of an economic boost during construction and beyond, from contractors to caterers, tradies and trainers – local businesses reaping benefits throughout construction and operation. Does she know location of the venue? It is within walking distance of 4-way intersection in Capalaba, off Old Cleveland Road East, congested week days a.m. and p.m. with commuter traffic. This because we, the people of Redland City, are dependent on personal transport. Public transport is poor. Too many people have already been killed or maimed at or near the Capalaba 4-way intersection. The promised Metro bus from City Hall to Capalaba is unlikely to lessen traffic congestion on existing roads.
An industrial sized canoe-racing facility, built on core koala habitat, will be using massive excavation equipment, concreted roads, supply trucks, destruction of koala habitat, adding to air and noise pollution where, directly opposite entry, a new housing estate was recently completed.
Can Ms Young explain upgrades to surrounding roads Redlanders can hope to see? Recently, a young male riding his bike near the entry was struck by a utility and taken to hospital with two broken legs. This young man’s life may never be the same. We hear sirens every day. Too many young people have died on Finucane Rd between the 4-way intersection and Alexandra Hills.
Ms Young claims the venue would be a year-round training base for elite and local athletes…a true investment in Queensland’s sporting future. Can this be believed? In past years, Olympians used the pool in Cleveland. In recent years, residents have asked for the pool to be upgraded but all requests fell on deaf ears.
A lifeguard inquired recently on who decided the Birkdale land was the right place for a Whitewater facility as, whoever it was, does not live in the area. We do know ex LNP Federal MP Andrew Laming convinced the Feds to release the land to Redland Council for Community use. Years have passed, and the only time the community was permitted to view the site, was when people were invited over a 2-day period in 2021, writing wishes on boards provided on what they would like to see on the land. The prominently displayed Whitewater facility information was ignored. People young and old, wanted nature based projects, walkways, saving koala habitat….a place to escape stresses of everyday life…away from air and noise pollution.
Finally, is MP Rebecca Young aware 75% of Redlands community surveyed, do not want the Birkdale land to have a wrecking ball destroy it to please certain politicians/developers for a small segment of the community who like canoe racing in turbulent waters?
Sensible politicians, Senator Matt Canavan and Gold Coast Mayor Tom Tate among them, expressed their views at the Senate inquiry that the Redlands Community must not be burdened with maintenance costs into the future of an unwanted sporting facility. The area should, instead, be a community precinct.
A.E.G.
Capalaba
Are you using Russian oil to fill up your car?

Are you using Russian oil to fuel your car? Dr Graham Manning suggests that evasion of some sanctions is actively enabled by the Australian Government.
He cited Australia’s purchasing of fuel refined from Russian oil in other countries as being either a failure to understand how global supply chains enable sanctions evasion, or a deliberate act of self-interest in ‘wanting full and unrestricted liquid energy supply’.
Dr Manning went on to say, ‘We have created a loophole that is legal, but, is not measured or defined, and is not being acted upon by our Parliament. We have failed to introduce a review mechanism of this loophole at the time of granting it. If we have reviewed it, we are comfortable with its implications for Ukraine. If that is the case, it is a national disgrace.’
But should you as an Australian, be interested? Well, yet another shipload of Russian petroleum is about to arrive in South Australia from an Indian refinery.
Australia has spent millions of your tax dollars supporting Ukraine with equipment, training and material. We have publicly sanctioned Putin and Russia over the deaths of Ukrainian and Russian people, and the destruction and disruption caused by his war.
Yet why should you care when you fill up your vehicle’s tank? You are essentially giving your hard earned money to Putin? Well, by using Russian oil, you and I are indirectly helping Putin break the very sanctions the Australian government has introduced. This allows Putin to fund his war.
O.P.
Cleveland
More letters to Redlands2030
Sirromet and the Southern Thornlands PDA – in letters
Swimming pools, whitewater, the Olympics – in letters


